The Governance Facilitators have placed a ratification poll into the voting system as part of the responsibilities defined in MIP51. This Governance Poll will be active for fourteen days beginning on Monday, November 14 at 16:00 UTC.

This is a binary vote.

• You may vote for a single option.
• You should vote for the option which you prefer.
• If you would accept either option, you should vote 'Abstain'.

Review

The community may vote in this poll to express support or opposition to MIP84c10-SP1 being accepted and implemented in the Maker Protocol.

A brief summary of this proposal has been provided by the MIP Author and is shown below:

"Set the upper limit way above the size of the surplus buffer (a.k.a. defuse the MIP84 bomb)."

"Risk has commented on the loss reserves needed for on-chain assets, but not real-world assets. It remains unclear where the loss reserves for real-world assets are supposed to come from."

"Leveraged purchase of stETH puts Maker in serious risk of insolvency in the case of a market downturn."

"The size of the Surplus Buffer already limits our ability to invest. See 1 and 2."

"It would be good to raise the Dai Savings Rate above zero to grow the demand to hold DAI."

"It would be nice to return some money back to MKR holders through flap auctions."

"There is pending engineering work:

• DssKiln is not deployed in production yet.
• We need a detailed analysis of what happens to “protocol owned” vaults in the event of Emergency Shutdown."

Please review the links below to inform your position on this proposal before voting.

• Canonical Proposal Version
• Latest Proposal Version
• Proposal Discussion Thread

Outcomes

This poll implements a Minimum Positive Participation value. The Minimum Positive Participation is currently set to 10,000 MKR.

If the votes for the 'Yes' option exceed the votes for the 'No' option AND the votes for the 'Yes' option exceed 10,000 MKR, then the following actions will be taken:

• The MIP Editors will mark the proposal Accepted and the Governance Facilitators will confirm its passage on the Governance and Risk call on Thursday, December 1.
• Any further work required to implement the proposal will be tasked to the relevant Core Units.

Otherwise, this proposal will be marked as rejected per MIP51.

Resources

MIP51: Monthly Governance Cycle describes this type of poll and its position and significance within the rest of the governance cycle.

If you are new to voting in the Maker Protocol, please see the voting guide to learn how voting works, and this wallet setup guide to set up your wallet to vote.

Additional information about the Governance process can be found in the Governance section of the MakerDAO community portal.

To participate in future Governance calls, please join us every Thursday at 17:00 UTC.

To add current and upcoming votes to your calendar, please see the MakerDAO Public Events Calendar.